Problem 8: Of Knights and Knaves

There is a famous type of problem about an island inhabited by two types of people: knights and knaves. Knights always tell the truth and knaves always lie.

1. You meet a pair of islanders, Liam and Noel.

Liam says: “Both Noel and I are knaves.”

Is Liam a knight or a knave? What about Noel?

2. You meet a group of three islanders, Beyoncé, Kelly and Michelle.

Beyoncé says: “Kelly is the same type as me.”

Kelly says: “Michelle is a knave.”

Michelle says: “Beyoncé is a knave.”

What types of people are Beyoncé, Kelly and Michelle?

3. While out for a walk you get lost and come to a fork in the road. Two islanders, Sonny and Cher, are there. As islanders they know each other, and they also know which way leads back to your hotel.

Sonny says: “Cher is a knave.”

What question can you ask, and who do you ask it to, to find out whether to take the left fork or the right fork?

Visit our School

Discover our school and stunning grounds at our next Open Morning on Saturday 26 September 2026 or Midweek Talk and Tour.

Open Morning Midweek Talk and Tour