
There is a question that I would love to hear more often in mathematics classrooms. It is a question that can be mildly inconvenient for a teacher trying to finish a lesson, but it goes to the very heart of what mathematics is about.
But why is it true ?
Much of school mathematics is concerned, quite understandably, with finding correct answers. Pupils learn methods, practise techniques and develop the fluency needed to solve increasingly sophisticated problems. These are essential foundations. But there is an important difference between knowing how to do something and understanding why it works.
And it is that second question which opens the door to mathematics as a genuinely intellectual pursuit.
A little mathematical mystery.
Here is something to try.
Choose any odd number, square it and subtract 1.
If you start with 3, you get 8. Start with 5, and you get 24. Try 7, and the answer is 48. With 9, you get 80.
There is something interesting about these answers. They are all multiples of 8.
Try a few more. It keeps happening.
We might begin to suspect that the square of any odd number is always one more than a multiple of 8.
But how could we possibly know that this is true for every odd number?
We could test a hundred examples, or a million. A computer could check billions of them. Yet however many we checked, there would always be infinitely many more.
This is where mathematics becomes particularly interesting. Rather than asking whether the pattern continues, we can ask why it must continue.
Every odd number can be written as 2n+1, where n is an integer.
Squaring this gives:
(2n + 1)² = 4n² + 4n + 1
Subtracting 1, we have:
4n² + 4n = 4n(n + 1)
Now comes the crucial observation. Of any two consecutive integers, one must be even. So n(n+1) must be divisible by 2.
And that means 4n(n+1) must be divisible by 8.
We have proved our conjecture.
Notice what has happened. We have not simply checked more examples or found a more efficient calculation. We have discovered something about the structure of odd numbers that explains why the result could never be otherwise.
And once we have understood the argument, we no longer need to test another example.
The difference between evidence and proof
This distinction is one of the things that makes mathematics extraordinary.
In the sciences, we investigate the world through observation and experiment, building explanations that are tested against evidence. In mathematics, we can establish certain conclusions through logical argument, starting from clearly stated assumptions.
A mathematical proof does not tell us that something is probably true, or that it has worked in every example examined so far. It establishes that a conclusion follows necessarily from its premises.
Of course, finding a proof can be much harder than discovering a pattern.
Mathematicians frequently begin with observations, experiments and conjectures, just as our young mathematician might begin by investigating the squares of odd numbers
But a conjecture is not a theorem, however convincing the evidence may appear
Indeed, mathematical history contains many examples of patterns that seemed compelling until somebody found a counterexample. One famous example concerns the expression n²+n+41, which produces prime numbers for every whole-number value of n from 0 to 39. It is a remarkable run, but at n=40 the expression gives 1681=41², which is certainly not prime.
Forty successful examples are not enough. Neither would four million be enough.
The point is not that experimenting is unimportant. Quite the opposite: experimenting is often how mathematics begins. But proof is what allows us to move from observing a pattern to understanding a necessary truth.
Proof is about more than being right
There is another reason why proof matters, and I think it is sometimes overlooked.
A good proof does not merely establish that a statement is true. It can reveal why it is true.
The proof about odd squares is a modest example. It shows us that the result depends on the relationship between consecutive integers. That observation is more interesting, and potentially more useful, than the original list of numbers.
Some of the most beautiful mathematical proofs are valued not simply because they establish a result, but because they illuminate unexpected connections between different areas of mathematics.
Two proofs of the same theorem can be entirely correct, yet one may provide a much deeper insight than the other.
This is one reason mathematicians care so much about elegance. A proof that reveals the underlying structure of a problem can change how we think about mathematics itself.
It is also why mathematical proof is such a powerful educational experience. When children construct their own arguments, they learn to distinguish what they know from what they suspect, to recognise hidden assumptions and to explain their reasoning in a way that another person can scrutinise.
They discover that an answer is not necessarily an explanation.
What does this mean for teaching mathematics?
I would not suggest that every mathematics lesson should consist of formal proofs. Young people need to develop technical fluency, mathematical knowledge and confidence in using established methods. There are times when practising a technique is exactly the right thing to do.
But pupils should also encounter mathematics as a subject in which ideas can be investigated, questioned and justified.
We should encourage them to ask whether a result is always true, to search for counterexamples and to explain why a method works rather than simply demonstrating that it does.
And we should give them time to think.
Sometimes a pupil will notice a pattern but be unable to explain it. Sometimes an argument will contain a gap. Sometimes a conjecture will turn out to be false. These are not failures of mathematical learning. They are part of the process through which mathematical understanding develops.
At 1729 Maths School, this is central to our approach. Alongside developing strong mathematical foundations, we want pupils to encounter unfamiliar ideas, make conjectures, construct arguments and learn to communicate their reasoning with precision.
Our ambition is not simply that they should know more mathematics. It is that they should begin to understand what it means to do mathematics.
But what about artificial intelligence?
There is a new urgency to all of this.
Artificial intelligence is becoming increasingly capable of solving mathematical problems, constructing arguments and contributing to mathematical research. It is reasonable to ask why young people should devote so much time to learning mathematics when machines may eventually be able to perform many of its most demanding tasks.
I think the answer lies in the distinction between knowing that something is true and understanding why it is true.
Mathematics is one of humanity's most powerful ways of making sense of the world. It allows us to describe patterns, identify relationships, construct models and reason with extraordinary precision. Mathematical proof gives us something particularly valuable: a means of establishing conclusions through arguments that can be examined, questioned and understood.
AI may increasingly help us discover mathematical truths, and that is something to welcome. But a result produced by a machine does not automatically become part of our own understanding. We still need people who can interpret mathematical ideas, recognise their significance, understand the assumptions on which they depend and appreciate what they tell us about the world.
This is not simply about checking whether a machine has made a mistake. It is about preserving and developing our own capacity to understand.
Indeed, the more powerful our mathematical tools become, the more important that capacity may be.
We should teach young people mathematics not merely so that they can produce correct answers, but so that they can make sense of those answers. We want them to ask why, to recognise when an explanation is incomplete and to experience the extraordinary satisfaction of understanding something that previously seemed mysterious.
A machine may be able to tell us that something is true. The desire to understand why remains one of the most compelling reasons for human beings to do mathematics.